>
Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket

Monday, September 13, 2010

How will MY marriage affect YOURS?

Ahhh...the inevitable question. 

Funny, because a very similar question was asked when No-Fault Divorce was pushed on us.  How will your neighbor's divorce affect your marriage? 

Advocates of No-Fault Divorce argued
  • Few people will be affected,
  • Children will be better off it their parents are divorced and happy,
  • We're lowering the cost of divorce for a handful of people,
  • Studies show it will be "ok", and besides
  • How can their divorce hurt you?
To be clear, previous to no-fault divorce you had "FAULT" divorce.  Every state had their own grounds for divorce, but virtually all of them included adultery, abuse, cruelty or desertion.  For any of these reasons, one could get divorced. 

But what we have now is UNILATERAL divorce.  In other words, one person wants a divorce and the other is forced to accept this decision.  As a result of no-fault divorce, the State expands it's power, authority, and cost. SEVENTY PERCENT of divorces are unilateral.  In these cases, the State must step in and enforce the wishes of the one spouse.  A Judge is forced to separate children from a parent and decide who gets what. 

Most unilateral divorces are initiated by women, and most of these women are not necessarily worse off economically for having divorced.  The Journal of Socio-Economics notes that child support serves as an "economic incentive for middle class women to seek divorce."  The majority of time, dads are told when, where and how much time they can spend with their children and how much money to send, and moms are told if and where they're allowed to move.  The State creates dead-beat dads, and as a result the State must create programs to help the children that suffer. 

As a general trend, children from disrupted homes do worse in every area than children from intact homes.  They have more physical and mental problems.  Fatherless boys are more likely to be aggressive and ultimately be incarcerated.  The Institute for American Values notes that the government's total annual cost of fatherlessness is $112 BILLION a YEAR. 

Since the inception of no-fault divorce, which was only supposed to affect a handful of people who would have gotten divorced anyway,
  • marriage rates have fallen and cohabitation rates have increased.  People have lost confidence in the institution.
  • Studies show that people are less likely to invest in their marriages.  Spouses are less likely to put their spouse through college.
  • Spouses are less likely to have a child together. 
  • The rate of divorce has increased by 10-20%, depending on the study. 
  • More women work outside the home in order to self-insure against the probability of divorce. 
  • People marry at a later age. 

It is clearly concluded, that changing the availability of divorce has affected the permanence of marriage and changed the behavior of millions.  And yet we are told that changing the definition of marriage will not affect anyone. 

And we naively believe it.

(Thanks to Dr. Jennifer Roback Morse at the Ruth Institute for this great information!  Click the button on my sidebar for more great information on marriage!)


13 comments:

Lisa said...

GREAT post. GREAT.

Megan said...

This is an awesome post!!! I am learning so much in regard to no fault divorce these days! It is so sad! :(
I totally see the parallels here! Very well written!
We humans tend to think we have it all figured out in theory, and then we realized all the problems that we failed to see when it's too late...

Megan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
MB said...

You know this happened to my friend - he did NOT want a divorce.. refused to sign the papers, in fact. And still he is divorced because - in short - his wife "didn't ever really love him". That's. it. GOOD parallel!

Anonymous said...

Wonderfully written, Lauren. Thanks!

AnniePhil said...

I like this post. Thanks for writing it. I would try to comment with something more profound and discussion-worthy, BUT I HAVE TO GO BACK AND LOOK AT THOSE BABY GIRL PICTURES AGAIN RIGHT NOW AND CAN'T MANAGE TO THINK ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE!

Karen said...

Great post! This happened to someone in my dh's family a few years ago. It's so sad! He came home one day after only 1 1/2 years of marriage, his wife said she wanted a divorce. She said she was thinking about someone else the day they got married. He had no choice in the matter. It was so unbelievably sad.

Leila@LittleCatholicBubble said...

No-fault divorce is one of the scourges of our time. It has hurt so many innocent people. And that is the tragedy... that it's the innocent party (and the innocent children) who are the victims of no-fault divorce. I've seen it play out in real life. It's the one thing I am upset with Ronald Reagan about, since he introduced and advocated it in California, I believe.

Thanks for this post, Lauren!! But now I need to know more about baby girl!!!!!!!!!!

Miss G said...

Hi Lauren,

Interesting post. I agree with you that divorce greatly affects everyone around, whether you're a friend of someone divorcing or the child of parents getting a divorce.

I'm just wondering though-wouldn't a no-fault divorce be a safety-net option for women (or men) trying to escape an abusive marriage? What if an abusing spouse refuses to grant a divorce? If you run away or leave the marriage, you can still run into all sorts of legal/financial problems is you're legally still married. I'm just saying...

Also, while I agree divorce takes a toll on everyone, I'd add that I don't think same-sex marriage is a threat to anyone trying to get married in a heterosexual union. I know, I know, it's a liberal's response. But I don't see the threat.

I hope your next post is all about a successful adoption with baby girl!

Cathy said...

PLEASE update soon or I will throw up.

Love and prayers...

Anonymous said...

Oh my gosh, women working outside the home and people marrying at an older age are bad things?!!!!

Those sound like tremendous strides to me. Women working outside the home protects a family from exactly the kind of economic situation we are experiencing today. A couple with only one working spouse is at much more risk in the case of death, disability, mental illness, job layoffs, etc.

As for people marrying at older ages, countless studies have shown that waiting until people are mature and ready to embark in marriage leads to much higher marital satisfaction and lower divorce rates.

Sorry, this still proves nothing about extending rights to a group that hasn't had them. If gay people are allowed to marry will that really affect your marriage? Will it really change how you would raise children? That just doesn't make logical sense. You are comparing altering a right that a group already has to granting a right to a group that has not yet had it. The same arguments have been used with minorities and women getting the vote, or people of different races marrying, that it would "disrupt" society. But the call of freedom and progress must be heeded.

And BTW, go to any battered women's shelter and ask whether no-fault divorce is critical for being able to remove a woman from a life-threatening situation.

I continue to pray for all of you to my god, a god of love and compassion, that you will open your hearts.

Frank said...

On the bright side, there is one state where divorce rates have steadily dropped, to the point that they’re now as low as they’ve been since before World War II. Wanna guess which state? Go on, guess.


…Massachusetts!

(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-wilson/divorce-rate-in-gay-marri_b_267259.html)

Sorry, what were you saying about the dangers of redefining marriage? :)

But I’m sure banning gay marriage would make the divorce rate go down, even there. Oh, wait: “Divorce rates higher in states with gay marriage bans”

(http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2010/01/divorce-rates-appear-higher-in-states.html)

BTW, I'm tired of always being the guy that argues with you. CONGRATS and post pictures as soon as you can!

Sarah said...

Lauren - sorry I am so late here, but just saw this post and thought it was great! There is so much to be said about unilateral divorce.

Frank - not only are divorce rates lower in MA, so are marriage rates - lower than the US average. So if less people are getting married, period, then it isn't so surprising or impressive that less people are getting divorced.