Let me explain...
B.P. was terribly negligent and MUST pay for every bit of damages it caused.
But B.P. was not alone in this. And the Federal Government's finger pointing is not only childish and dishonest, but it is destructive and harming us all.
After Exxon Valdez, the oil companies got together and lobbied the government to cap their damages, should a spill of such magnitude occur in the future. "Who would agree to that?" you ask yourself. The Federal Government would. Section 1004 of the Oil Pollution Act limited the liability of oil companies to $75 million per spill, plus removal costs. In exchange, the oil companies agreed to the stricter regulations by the government.
When B.P. wanted to drill off the coast of Louisiana, they asked the state for permission to drill in 500 feet of water. Louisiana agreed, but the Feds said no way and moved them out to 5,000 feet. As a result, B.P. drilled in an area where
- no oil company had ever been able to monitor the flow, nor was
- the government able to to tell B.P. how to monitor the flow, and
- the law of the land limited the liability of B.P.
But now, the government is changing the rules in the middle of the game. They're changing the law retro-actively, and the ability to do this gives a HUGE amount of power to the Federal Government. Vice-President Joe Biden threatened the chair of B.P. to establish a TWENTY BILLION DOLLAR escrow fund, which B.P. neither has nor owes (at this point) according to the law. VP Biden threatened B.P. to 'to give us the money or we'll take it' without the due process of law. Where is the authority in the Constitution OR precedent of law to do this? Don't get me wrong, B.P. is responsible, but the government doesn't have the right to seize assets!! If the government can seize private property from B.P., who's to say they won't seize YOUR assets when it is popular or convenient to do so? (Think guns or gold.)
But as Rahm Emanuel famously said, "Never let a crisis go to waste!" They will use this emergency to destroy capitalism by pushing through cap and trade legislation.
By demonizing B.P., the executive branch has effectively reduced the stock's value by half. What does this do for the innocent stock-holders? How does this help the local franchise owners who are just trying to support their families?
I leave you with two questions:
- What's better, a rich B.P. who has the cash to pay for cleaning up the oil spill and repair the damages, or a poor B.P.?
- Who would spend the money more effectively? B.P. who wants the most bang for their buck, or the Government who couldn't care less about the cost and will simply repay favors for friends, whether or not they're effective.
7 comments:
Great post! I couldn't agree more!
Awesome! Very well said!
Oh boy, I couldn't agree more. I've been thinking of posting about this but cannot get my thoughts together nearly as well as you have. It makes me FURIOUS how people have this knee jerk reaction, instantly hating BP as "evil" bad guys when it's the government that put the first nail in this disaster.
And one thing that you so aptly pointed out is the fact that BP was NOT alone... Halliburton provided construction materials, Transocean made the blowout preventer, and it happened at a Deepwater Horizon well. BP is definitely getting dragged through the... oil sludge... on this, but it's never as clear-cut as Obama would like to make it. This could be a time to focus on designing proactive solutions for the future and collaborating in the moment, but no... everyone is just pointing fingers.
I agree, very well said. The administration definitely isn't doing anything to actually help the situation.
Thanks for the post. It's funny how none of that historical perspective is being discussed in the media. Just further evidence that we have all but lost the ability to look backward in retrospect, learn from the past (or at least admit past mistakes and failures), and use the lessons and poor decisions of history to avoid making worse ones in the future.
It is crazy the need in our society to place blame with such elementary understanding! Well said!
Post a Comment